Bicycle Safety through Defensive Riding
By Dirk H. Dugan. MD
Like many Tompkins
County residents, I enjoy
riding my bicycle during the summer. In an ideal world we would be able to ride
for the simple pleasure of being outdoors in beautiful surroundings, without
having to pay close attention to safety issues. However, as an orthopedic
surgeon, I am all too familiar with the risk people on bicycles and motorcycles
take when they do not drive defensively. Every summer my colleagues and I see
too many serious injuries and deaths resulting from bicycle and motorcycle
Seeing and perceiving
In taking care of the cyclists who survive accidents involving cars, the
most common response we hear from the driver of the car is, "I never saw
him!" This often occurs when the driver is making a left-hand turn at an
intersection (or anywhere along a road) and in doing so, pulls directly into
the path of a cyclist riding through the same intersection. It also happens
when a driver at a stop sign looks for oncoming cars and seeing none, pulls out
of the intersection and into an oncoming cyclist.
Even when they see each other coming, we hear about perception problems on
the part of motorists and cyclists who are involved in accidents. Drivers and
cyclists both misjudge how fast the other vehicle is traveling toward them.
Motorists in particular miscalculate the speed of the oncoming bicycle and
assume they can make their left-hand turn at the intersection before the
bicycle reaches it. Cyclists may have the right of way in these cases, but if
the car driver does not see the bicycle or motorcycle, the cyclist may end up
in the right but seriously injured nevertheless. When I am riding my bicycle, I
ride with the assumption that cars and trucks do not see me and I act accordingly.
Babies and biking
Given that we know perception problems on the part of drivers cause
accidents, bicycle riders should understand that the problem is compounded when
pulling a child behind you in a trailer. Some of these carriages ride so low
that drivers don't see them at all, which puts the child at risk. We have found
that even motorcycle sidecars are unsafe in many situations because, like the
baby trailers, drivers often don't see them.
Following the rules of the road
Following the rules of the road is a basic tenant of cycling safety, yet
some cyclists believe the traffic laws pertain to motor vehicles only. We've
all seen bicyclists slow down at traffic lights and stop signs, and then slide
through the intersection. While the majority of riders obey
the law, those who don't run the risk of major injury because they can misjudge
the speed of oncoming cars or simply don't see them. Stopping at traffic
lights and stop signs eliminates this risk. Bicyclists can make a left-hand
turn as a pedestrian and obey the traffic lights by dismounting and taking the
crosswalk, without running through a red light.
Defensive riding means slowing down
While it is great fun to ride fast, it increases your risk of losing control
when you encounter too much dust or loose gravel in the road. When cyclists
ride through oil on the road while traveling at high speed and the tires become
covered, it can become difficult to stop. All of these problems are easier to
handle safely if the cyclist is traveling at a safe speed. I encourage cyclists
to travel down the Ithaca
hills slowly and to take curves at the bottom very slowly. Pedestrians, dogs,
and other animals may not see you coming and these collisions injure everyone
Defensive driving also means watching for the unexpected and staying a
reasonable distance behind vehicles ahead. We've treated cyclists injured by
things falling out of trucks and hitting the cyclist or landing directly in the
path of the cyclist. Metal bridges with grates and uneven or broken road can
trip up the best cyclists when tires get caught. And collisions with chasing
dogs can result in broken legs for both the cyclist and the canine.
Cycling accidents can result in very bad injuries that cause permanent
disability and even death. When you climb on board your two-wheel vehicle this
summer, whether it is a bicycle or a motorcycle, please ride defensively. I
would rather pass you pedaling on a country road than see you at the hospital.
Dr. Dugan is board certified in
orthopedic surgery and serves on the medical staff at Cayuga Medical
Center. He is in practice
at Orthopedic Surgery and Sports Medicine in Ithaca and can be reached at (607) 272-7000.
Dr. Dugan completed his residency in orthopedic surgery at the renowned
Hospital for Special Surgery at Weill Medical College
of Cornell in New York City.
He earned his undergraduate degree from Cornell
University and went on for his medical
degree at SUNY Buffalo.
He then completed his surgical internship at North Shore
in Manhasset prior to his orthopedic residency.